Cookie Monster Cookie Recipe {LOADED!}

Everyone will love this simple Cookie Monster Cookie Recipe! It’s loaded with a variety of cookies while being able to enjoy all the flavors at once. The blue coloring and googly eyes are a throwback to your beloved Sesame Street monster friend!

Blue cookie monster cookies like this prove that cookies should be fun to eat – and fun to look at! Use these for birthday cookies, party treats, or after-school snacks. As long as you make them, you can’t go wrong!

This cookie monster TikTok viral recipe is popular for a reason. Not only are they simple to make, but you probably already have all the ingredients at home.

The best part about making this Cookie Monster Chocolate Chips Cookies Recipe is that you can grab one for each hand! Let’s check out the finished recipe so you can see why they’re so popular and addictive!

Let’s Check out this EASY Cookie Monster Cookie Recipe!

When I say that this is the best cookie monster cookies recipe, I mean it. It’s adorably delicious for the kids, and a fun treat for adults too! The blue coloring is optional, but I highly recommend it to give these cookies that fun Sesame Street vibe.

Blue cookie monster cookies like this are what make homemade treats the best. Just make sure that everyone knows that they’re likely to have a blue mouth after they take a bite!

Just look at all those cookies! They may look complicated, but I assure you that they’re not. These simple cookies won’t even need an explanation because one look and everyone will know that they’re supposed to be the cookie monster!

Big Bird himself would agree that these cookies are a must! Make sure to have the kids join in on the dessert-making fun so that they can have pride in helping to make these treats.

Do you know what they say? Those who bake together stay together and treat their tastebuds at the same time. This recipe is the perfect way to bring everyone together.

We love making unique cookie recipes at all times of the year. Cookie monster cookies prove that boring cookies don’t have to be a “thing.” Use this recipe as a way to try something new! Be sure to check out our Hocus Pocus Cookies Recipe {BUBBLY LIFE POTION!} for even more unique cookie ideas!

How to Make this SIMPLE Cookie Monster Cookies Recipe!

EASY Cookie Monster Cookie Recipe

Prep Time: 15 minutes

Cook Time: 12 minutes

Makes: 24-26 Cookies

If you want to double or triple this cookie recipe, you can easily do so. Just make sure that you give yourself enough prep time and baking time to cook them all.

With a bake time of only 12 minutes per baking sheet, doubling or tripling the recipe won’t take a ton of extra effort. Add this to your list of cookies to make asap!

EASY Cookie Monster Cookie Recipe Ingredients

1 cup of softened unsalted butter

1 cup of light brown sugar

¾ cup of granulated sugar

2 eggs

2 teaspoon vanilla

Blue gel food coloring 

1 teaspoon salt

2 teaspoon baking powder

3 cups flour

¾ cup of milk chocolate chips

¾ cups of white chocolate chips

1 ½ cups. of Oreo pieces

1 ½ cups of mini Chips Ahoy cookie pieces

Candy eyeballs – small and large

Stand Mixer

Cookie Sheet

How to Make This Cookie Monster Cookie Recipe Step By Step

STEP ONE – Cream Butter and Sugars

Preheat the oven to 350 degrees. Add parchment paper to a cookie sheet and set aside. Cream the butter and all the sugars in a bowl until fluffy and smooth. Add the vanilla and eggs and stir again until well combined and fluffy.

STEP TWO – Add the Food Coloring

Mix in the blue food coloring and stir until you get that signature COOKIE MONSTER color. Be sure to scrape down the sides and check the bottom of the bowl for hidden cookie dough!

STEP THREE – Add the Dry Ingredients

Add the dry ingredients to the wet ingredients (salt, baking powder and flour) and mix to combine.

STEP FOUR – Fold in the Chocolate Chips

Fold in chocolate chips and white chocolate chips until combined and well distributed throughout the cookie dough.

STEP FIVE – Roll Dough Into Balls & Add Toppings

Take a golf ball sized amount of dough and roll it into a ball. Place it onto your prepared cookie sheet. Bake no more than 6-9 cookies per sheet (I personally only bake 6 per sheet). If the cookies are too close together they will spread during the baking process and not hold that nice round shape. Add the cookie pieces on the top of the dough and press them down into the dough BEFORE baking. Save the eyeballs for after baking (don’t put them in the oven or they will melt!).

STEP SIX – Bake the Cookies

Put the cookie dough balls and baking sheet in the 350 degree oven and bake for 12 minutes. Be careful not to overcook and brown the cookies too much. When the edges are set and the center is no longer shiny you can remove from the oven. Before the cookies cool completely, press the googly eyes into the cookies. For the best effect use eyes in various sizes. Place on a rack to cool!

Cookie Monster Cookies Pro-tips:

• Cookies can be stored in an airtight container for up to 7 days or frozen for 3 months.
• You control the color of the cookies. If you want a light blue, add a few drops of food coloring. If you want a darker blue, add more.

• Don’t overcrowd the cookies on the baking pan. You’ll only be able to cook 6-9 cookies at one time.

• The cookies are really simple to break into pieces, but you can use a food processor if need be.

I hope you enjoyed learning how to make cookie monster cookies step by step. If you love these Sesame Street desserts be sure to check out some of our other EASY cookie recipes that you can make at home!

EASY Melted Snowman Cookies Recipe

EASY NO BAKE Vampire Fang Cookies

Hocus Pocus Cookies Recipe {BUBBLY LIFE POTION!}

Save Our Cookie Monster Cookie Recipe for Later on Pinterest!